Interviewing at CareMessage: An Overview
CareMessage wouldn’t exist without our amazing and talented team members so we work hard to ensure our mission and our values are reflected in our hiring plan. As CareMessage has grown we have spent a lot of time experimenting and refining our approach to hiring. We’ve received feedback from potential candidates and our own employees on how we can improve our process, and we’ve worked on redesigning it to reflect that feedback.
In this blog post, we provide an overview of our interview stages so that you, as an applicant, can gain a better understanding of what to expect when you interview at CareMessage. We’ll also provide some context to our interview pipeline so you can better understand why we made the choices we did in designing it this way.
Interview Steps
We have organized our interviews into standardized steps that we follow regardless of the role, department or level associated with the position you are interviewing for. Our structured approach attempts to mitigate bias and ensure a fair evaluation for all our candidates.
Stage 1: Application Review
Our process begins when we first receive your application. Each job has a hiring manager who is responsible for reviewing resumes and answers to our application form questions. The hiring manager looks for the required skills that are described in the job description as well as the quality of the responses to the application questions. We don’t have any hidden requirements. At this stage, we are only screening for relevant experience as described in the public job posting.
Stage 2: Phone Screen
Once you’ve passed the resume review stage, we schedule a 20-30 minute call to discuss your interest in the position, learn more about your work experience, and your interest in our mission. We also save some time to answer your questions about the company, the role or the next steps. This step may be completed by one of our recruiters or the hiring manager.
In order to ensure equity and fairness in compensation across our diverse team, we have defined a series of non-negotiable compensation bands based on the levels in our career ladder. The career ladder serves as a canonical reference for each level of career development that is possible at CareMessage and is what determines the salary that is listed on the job post. The salary is pre-determined, shared transparently and publicly, and is not negotiable.
Stage 3: Behavioral Interview
At this stage you will have a call to discuss your experiences most relevant to the role. We usually go a bit broad with the questions to assess your skills and experience with some of the top requirements of the role. This interview is completed by the hiring manager.
Stage 4: Case Study or Work Sample
Depending on the role you apply to, this stage can consist of a take-home programming test, a case study or some similar evaluation of your skills. The take-home assignment is followed by a video call to discuss your work and ask any follow-up questions. At this stage, you may be interviewed by a peer for your role and if so, you will have an opportunity to ask them questions about their day-to-day experience in the position you’re applying to. Most of our case studies do not have a clear right or wrong answer we are looking for, we are more interested in seeing how you approach problem solving.
Stage 5: Panel Interviews
Once you’ve done the case study, you’ll progress to our final stage of interviews. In this stage, you’ll jump on multiple video calls to speak with team members who you’re likely to work with frequently and with members of the leadership team. The panels you participate in may be determined by the role and level you are applying for. They generally include:
- Peer & Department Panel - Panel interview with people who may regularly collaborate with in your direct team or a team you will regularly work with. The interview will go deeper on skills and qualities critical for the role.
- Mission & Values Panel - Panel interview with one of our co-founders to revisit alignment with our mission and company values. The interview will assess previous experiences related to the work of CareMessage and may also prompt for examples that match the level you are interviewing at.
- People Management Panel - This panel only applies to roles that requires people management. This panel will go over your experiences across the entire workforce journey from hiring to exits. We want to understand areas you are strongest in and where you may need support.
- Board Panel - This panel only applies to executive team members. You may be asked to join a call with one or more board members who oversee areas related to the role you are applying for.
Please note that throughout these panels you may be asked the same question twice. This is intentional because we hire by a committee and we like to see each interviewer’s interpretation of your response. Interviewers do not see notes from your previous interviews, which is an intentional decision we have made to mitigate possible biases. This is our final stage of interviews.
Stage 6: Offer
When we reach our final committee decision, we will extend an offer to a candidate. As we finalize our offer, we may ask for contact information for two to three references who can speak to your previous work and values. Once the reference checks are complete, we are able to make a final decision.
Once we make a decision on your level in the career ladder, the hiring manager will provide a written offer letter and will set up a call to discuss the other benefits we offer. You can expect this follow-up within 3–5 days of the Reference Check stage.
Design Considerations
Next, we’ll describe some core considerations that went into the creation of our hiring plan, so you may understand the context behind our design choices.
Elimination of Interviewer Bias
We ask a standard set of questions to all candidates at each interview stage to attempt to eliminate bias in our hiring decisions. This may differ from interviews at other organizations who prefer a freeform style of interview. In our experience, freeform interviews are inconsistent in the answers they elicit from candidates and result in variability in responses. It becomes very difficult to evaluate two candidates for the same position when they have had inconsistent conversations with two different interviewers.
To some candidates, our approach may seem a bit robotic but we have found that it is the best way to ensure all candidates have an equal opportunity to speak to their skills and experience without relying on each individual interviewer’s conversational ability. We do our best to still make the interviews a conversation, but all interviewers do come in with a specific set of questions to get through.
Diversity and Inclusion
Diversity has been a core value at CareMessage since our founding. In order to most effectively serve our customers, we believe that our team needs to be representative of the various populations we serve.
We try to ensure that candidates of all backgrounds feel comfortable applying to our open positions and feel welcome throughout our interview process. We conduct trainings for all interviewers to ensure they follow the same procedures when conducting interviews. When creating job postings we try to ensure we use inclusive language in our descriptions of the ideal candidates for our roles. We try to ensure diversity in our team of interviewers to ensure candidates have an opportunity to speak with team members with various backgrounds.
At CareMessage, our focus on diversity and inclusion is directly tied to our commitment to health equity.
Time to Decision
A major focus of our design (and of our remote work ethic in general) is to ensure constant and speedy communication with candidates so we may arrive at a decision efficiently. We do our best to respond to questions from candidates as soon as we can. We revert with decisions on next steps within 72 hours of an interview whenever possible. We schedule time blocks in interviewer calendars to ensure candidates can schedule an interview as soon as they are available. In this way, we attempt to ensure a smooth, efficient and fair interview process for all applicants.
Parting Thoughts
We hope this post provides an informative overview and some meaningful context of our interview process. In essence, our goal is to run a hiring process that reduces interviewer bias, welcomes diversity in our organization and minimizes uncertainty for candidates interviewing with us. There is, of course, always room for improvement in our approach and we will continue to refine and improve it based on our own analysis and the feedback we receive from applicants and employees. If you ever have any questions, don’t hesitate to ask the hiring manager.
Good luck in your search and thank you for considering CareMessage!
P. S. Do you like what you see? Check out our open positions at: www.caremessage.org/careers